AroundTown - With help from a friend - Positioning
All,
Please find our updated model here.
AroundTown continues to make progress with its efforts to make the Company boring again. The results are non-events, with the Company making steady, slow progress operationally. But with unsecured still trading wide of 7%, AroundTown continues to increase its secured funding levels, as the unsecured rates are uneconomical at these levels. AroundTown have the headroom available to access the secured market but it is not viable over the medium term. In the meantime, however, AroundTown have sufficient liquidity, and with dividends likely to commence from Grand City Properties, an investment opportunity has opened up.
Investment Considerations:
- We are taking a 2% long position in the 5% perpetual bonds, 1st call July 2029 at 58%. We expect a continuation of recent trends of tightening spreads in the unsecured which will pull the perpetual bonds along. We have opted for the lowest priced recently issued perpetual, which at 58% gives an 8.5% running yield.
- But it should be noted, the position size is relatively small versus our normal position size, which reflects the risk associated with this position. LTV through the perpetuals is 73%, assigning zero value to AroundTown’s Grand City Properties stake. It increases to 80% if we assume the current equity value is the correct valuation of AroundTown’s assets.
- Downside in this position could easily be 10+ pts, especially if there is more than just a pause in the rates environment. Any adverse rates movement will have a disproportionate impact on the trading levels of property companies, with AroundTown exposed more to the less favoured segments, including Offices and Hotels.
- However, we expect dividends to commence flowing up from Grand City Properties, c. €100m p.a. which has a material impact on cashflow at AroundTown.
- This is a bullish view, and the logical extension of this view is to take a position in the equity instead of the perpetuals. However, with the perpetuals trading sub 60%, we expect both will share similar upside in the medium term.
Perpetual Notes Exchange:
- Like its listed subsidiary Grand City Properties, AroundTown also entered into a voluntary exchange offer, issuing 4 new perpetual notes totalling €2.1bn. The acceptance level was also relatively high, at c.80%, with only half choosing to tender.
- The new perpetuals are all S&P compliant, with the equity content regained. There is a small coupon cost but the main purpose of the exchange was to regain the 50% equity content. The first call date on the new perpetuals is July 2029, although there is a €600m original, non-tendered perpetual callable in July 2026.
Vendor Loan Notes:
- AroundTown uses Vendor Loan Notes to assist in the sale of assets, The Loans generally have a maturity of 1-3yrs and are paid off in instalments. The loans are secured, against the assets sold, and usually at a LTV less than 70%.
- AroundTown have €650m of outstanding Vendor Loan Notes. Excluding this amount, AroundTown have sufficient liquidity (cash) to meet upcoming maturities until H1 2025. This is different to what the Company states, as the Company also includes expected disposal proceeds from assets sold but not yet completed. Including these proceeds AroundTown have sufficient liquidity until Q1 2026.
- This paints a negative picture. AroundTown also have a very low secured debt LTV and have amble room to maintain current liquidity.
Recent Results:
- AroundTown have maintained LTV on a consolidated basis at 43%.
- However, standalone, AroundTown’s LTV is 53%, ignoring the value accruing to AroundTown from their Grand City Properties stake.
- AroundTown's Office portfolio (56% of standalone portfolio), which is 60% based in Berlin, Frankfurt, Munich and Amsterdam, has benefitted from improving prime rents coupled with the fact that some construction projects were cancelled in Q1. The German economy continues to lag, but recently has seen some slightly positive momentum. AroundTown recorded a 2.9% LFL rental growth as indexation and rent reversion compensated for some negative occupancy impact.
- Hotels, (30% of standalone), recorded a 2.3% LFL in Q1 with positive momentum expected in Q2 and Q3 from reopening of 3 hotels, and Euro 2024 and Olympic Games in Germany and Paris respectively.
- The Company did not revalue its estate as at March 31st, with the next valuation due as part of the H1 results. Grand City Properties continue to execute small divestments at are slightly above book value.
Development and Investment Portfolio:
- Historically, equity and credit investors enjoyed this additional exposure but times have changed. This segment accounts for c. 10% of AroundTown’s standalone portfolio, with the exposure evenly split between Offices (40%) Resi/mixed use (33%) and Hotels (28%). AroundTown have divested €800m of exposure via disposals of building rights etc. as the Company attempt to de-risk their portfolio.
- AroundTown are in cash conservation mode, taking only selective development of low risk projects, mainly refurbishments.
Next Steps:
- With no major upcoming maturities, we expect AroundTown to continue to secure additional liquidity from further asset sales and accessing the secured bank debt market. We do not envisage any new issuance of unsecured bonds, with Grand City Properties likely to be the first entity to try to access the unsecured bond market.
- There is some speculation surrounding the shareholders, but if the Company is in conversations about asset disposals, we see a low probability of any shareholder movement.
- There is a low, but not zero probability that AroundTown will seek to increase its stake in Grand City Properties. We can see the rationale for such a move, but it feels a little early in the cycle to take such a bold move.
- The Company will hold its AGM on the 25th June, with the H1 report due on the 27th August.
Tomás
E: tmannion@sarria.co.uk
T: +44 20 3744 7009
www.sarria.co.uk